The short answer: bangjja is hammered, cast yugi is poured
Yugijang are artisans who make tableware, musical instruments and other objects from bronze (nossoe). Yugi (鍮器) means objects made of nossoe bronze. Korea's National Intangible Heritage designation for yugijang covers two kinds of masters. Some work in the hammered bangjja technique. Others work in the cast technique, pouring molten metal into molds. This article is Part 1 of a six-part series.
According to the Korea Heritage Agency, Koreans long preferred white porcelain tableware in summer and yugi in winter. They also used yugi for many other household goods. The Korea Heritage Service notes that spoons, chopsticks and basic tableware such as rice bowls (jubal) and soup bowls (daejeop) were made of bronze. Folk percussion instruments such as bara cymbals, jing gongs and kkwaenggwari small gongs are also described as bronze instruments. In other words, the single word notgeureut, or bronzeware, covers both tableware and instruments, made by two distinct techniques.
Designated in 1983: three technique categories, two lines of holders
The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture is published by the Academy of Korean Studies. Its entry on yugijang states that the craft was designated a National Intangible Cultural Property (now National Intangible Heritage) in 1983. The academy's Encyclopedia of Korean Local Culture gives the exact date as June 1, 1983. The Korea Heritage Service divides yugi into three types by production technique: bangjja, cast and banbangjja (semi-bangjja). For the yugijang heritage designation, however, it distinguishes masters of the bangjja technique from masters of the cast technique.
The Korea Heritage Agency's artisan profiles trace both lines of holders. Lee Bong-ju (born 1926) was recognized as a holder on June 1, 1983. He became an honorary holder in 2013. His son Lee Hyeong-geun (born 1958) was then recognized as a holder in 2015. On the casting side, Kim Geun-su was recognized as a skill holder in 1983 and became an honorary holder in 2005. His son Kim Su-yeong inherited the cast yugi technique and was recognized as a skill holder in 2008. Kim Geun-su died in 2009.
The Chungju entry of the Encyclopedia of Korean Local Culture lists both current holders: Lee Hyeong-geun for bangjja yugi and Kim Su-yeong for cast yugi. These sources show that the classification of objects and the framework of the heritage designation do not exactly match. Objects fall into three techniques, but holders can be read as having been recognized along two of them. The sources also show that both lines passed from father to son. The original texts are available in the Academy of Korean Studies' Encyclopedia of Korean Culture and Encyclopedia of Korean Local Culture, and on the Korea Heritage Service website.
Four nyang of tin to one geun of copper: the Oju seojong bangmul gobyeon and differing alloy ratios
Bangjja yugi is made from nossoe, an alloy of copper and tin. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture's yugijang entry quotes a recipe for this bronze from the text Oju seojong bangmul gobyeon: "To make it, combine one geun of copper with four nyang of tin."
The same encyclopedia's bangjja yugi entry calls bronze of this ratio a high-quality alloy widely used in the Joseon period. It adds that this bronze was specifically called bangjja. A Korea Heritage Service article gives the mix as one geun of copper (600 g today) to four and a half nyang of tin (about 168.7 g). The Gimje entry of the Encyclopedia of Korean Local Culture gives one geun of copper (16 nyang, about 70–72%) to four nyang five don of tin (about 28–30%). Korea.net puts it at 78% copper and 22% tin. A paper in the Korean Journal of Metals and Materials examined 13 excavated Goryeo bronze vessels. All were copper-tin alloys containing 20–24 wt% tin.
Cast yugi uses different materials. According to the Korea Heritage Agency, it is made from brass, an alloy of copper and zinc, or from mixed metals. The Korea Heritage Service notes that the casting molds are made of soft tidal-flat clay. In bangjja work, once the shaping material called baduk has been produced, the fire is fed only with pine charcoal. Even with the same one geun of copper, some sources give four nyang of tin and others four and a half. Rather than memorizing one fixed ratio, check the basis each source uses.
From melting to finishing: nepim, jejil, quenching and the cast pouring process
The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture groups the bangjja process into three stages. First comes nossoe-buri (melting), then nepim and jejil (forging), and finally gajil (finishing). The Korea Heritage Agency breaks the process down further: melting, nepimjil, ugimjil, naemjil, dakchimjil, jejil and quenching, byeoreumjil, and gajil. In the melting stage, molten metal is poured onto a water plate. There it forms round alloy lumps shaped like go stones, called baduk.
In nepimjil, a team of workers heats the baduk in the fire and strikes it with hammers. They repeat this until the baduk is spread thin. According to the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, nepim and jejil, with their repeated hammering (mejil), define the technical character of bangjja yugi. The Korea Heritage Agency notes that quenching lowers the bronze's hardness and toughness, making it softer. In the final gajil stage, workers shave off the oxide film and flaws to bring out the metal's distinctive color. The paper in the Korean Journal of Metals and Materials states that the microstructure of Goryeo bronze vessels shows they were hot-forged and quenched after casting.
Cast yugi follows a different path. The Chungju entry of the Encyclopedia of Korean Local Culture says objects are made by pouring boiling molten metal into a casting mold called a hyangnam-teul. This pouring (bujil) process runs in order: melting, making the mold, sooting, pouring the metal, removing the object and quenching. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture names pouring the metal as the most important skill in the bujil method. According to the Korea Heritage Agency, cast yugi production is divided into bujilgan (casting), gajilgan (finishing) and jangsikgan (decorating) work. In the gajilgan, the most important tools are the gajilteul frame and the gajilkal knife. The two methods can be read as similar in that both involve quenching and gajil, and as parting ways at the stage where the form is shaped.
Gongs, spoons, ritual vessels, Napcheong and Anseong: uses, production centers and a comparison with Kerala bronze vessels
The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture's entry on Anseong yugi says yugi was widely used for tribute to the royal court, Buddhist implements and everyday goods. The Gimje entry of the Encyclopedia of Korean Local Culture notes that the Joseon royal house made its ritual vessels of yugi. Because yugi retains heat well, the court also used it as winter tableware. The Korea Heritage Service says the bangjja technique was used mainly for jing, kkwaenggwari and spoons. The reason is that bangjja allows thickness and size to be adjusted and corrected. Cast yugi, by contrast, can take freer forms and can be mass-produced with molds. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture gives candlesticks, incense burners and braziers as examples of cast yugi.
According to the Korea Heritage Service, Napcheong (納淸) in Pyeongan Province was famous for the bangjja technique, and Anseong in Gyeonggi Province for cast yugi. Napcheong was the old name for Cheongjeong-dong, Masan-myeon, Jeongju-gun, North Pyeongan Province. The Korea Heritage Agency cites the area's plentiful supply of hot-burning pine charcoal as an advantage. The agency also explains that Anseong yugi became famous because it was made to order for Seoul households, both yangban and commoner. Seo Yu-gu (徐有榘), author of the Imwon gyeongjeji (林園經濟志), noted that yugi was also made in Gurye, Gaeseong and Jeongju. Even so, he judged Anseong yugi the finest. The expression "Anseong-machum" (made to order in Anseong) is said to come from the fame of Anseong yugi and Anseong leather flower shoes.
Korea.net notes that traditionally China used ceramic tableware, Japan wooden tableware and Korea yugi. Korean bangjja can also be compared with bronze vessels from Palghat in the Indian state of Kerala. The Korean figures come from Korea Heritage Service materials; the Kerala figures come from a paper in the MRS Online Proceedings Library. Korean bangjja uses one geun of copper to four and a half nyang of tin, while the Kerala vessels are 23% tin bronze. In both places, the alloy is hammered and quenched to make vessels. Korean bangjja was used for tableware and for jing and kkwaenggwari. The Kerala paper covers vessels as well as mirrors made of a copper-tin alloy with 33% tin. The comparison shows that hammering and quenching bronze into vessels is not unique to Korea.
| Object | Alloy | How the form is shaped | Typical uses |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bangjja yugi (Korea) | One geun of copper to four and a half nyang of tin (Korea Heritage Service) | A team heats and hammers baduk cast from molten metal, then quenches and finishes it (gajil) | Jing, kkwaenggwari, spoons and chopsticks, tableware |
| Cast yugi (Korea) | Brass (a copper-zinc alloy) or mixed metals (Korea Heritage Agency) | Molten metal is poured into tidal-flat clay molds (bujil), then finished (gajil) | Candlesticks, incense burners, braziers |
| Excavated Goryeo bronze vessels | 13 copper-tin alloy pieces with 20–24 wt% tin (Korean Journal of Metals and Materials) | Hot-forged and quenched after casting | Vessels |
| Palghat vessels, Kerala, India | 23% tin bronze (MRS Online Proceedings Library paper) | Hammered and quenched | Vessels |
Summing up
Read together, these sources show that the bangjja–cast distinction runs consistently through alloy, shaping method, typical objects and production centers. Bangjja is linked to Napcheong and to jing, kkwaenggwari, spoons and chopsticks. Cast yugi is linked to Anseong and to candlesticks, incense burners and braziers. Alloy ratios, however, diverge even with the same one geun of copper: tin is given as four nyang or four and a half. The Korea Heritage Service names a third type, banbangjja yugi; readers can explore its process further in the original sources.
There are also clues you can look for in person. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture's bangjja yugi entry describes the surface marks: "The hammer marks made at this stage are sometimes left as they are, showing that the piece was made with the bangjja technique." Look for hammer marks on bronzeware in a museum or exhibition, and you can see the difference in technique for yourself. The next part examines the work of another craft master in the same way.