The short answer: the two books recorded Dangun's mother differently

Let me give the short answer first. The Samguk Yusa and the Jewang Ungi recorded Dangun's mother differently. The Samguk Yusa recorded a woman who had been transformed from a bear. The Jewang Ungi recorded a granddaughter of Hwanung. The Gojoseon passage in Book One of the Samguk Yusa relates it this way: "The bear who kept the taboo for samchil-il (三七日, 21 days) turned into a woman, but the tiger could not keep the taboo and did not become human."

The Jewang Ungi paints a different picture. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture has an entry comparing the two books. That entry renders the passage this way: "That is, the Bear Woman of the Samguk Yusa disappears and in her place a granddaughter of Hwanung appears. Hwanung has his granddaughter take medicine so that she takes on a human body, and then has her marry Dansusin (檀樹神)."

Another entry in the same encyclopedia tells it in similar terms. It records that he "had his granddaughter drink medicine so that she became human, and she married Dansusin (檀樹神) and gave birth to Dangun."

So why do the two records differ? One place to look is the sources each book relied on. The Samguk Yusa cited the Wei shu (魏書) and the Gogi (古記). The Jewang Ungi cited the Bongi.

However, no confirmed explanation identifies this difference in sources as the cause of the different accounts of the mother. Both books are records from the Goryeo period. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture only summarizes them as "similar in their basic content but showing differences in their detailed parts."

The Giipyeon of the Samguk Yusa: the earliest record, which cited the Wei shu and the Gogi

The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture points to the Giipyeon (紀異篇) of the Samguk Yusa as the earliest record concerning Gojoseon and Dangun. This record cited China's Wei shu and Korea's Gogi. The same encyclopedia records that no such content is written in the Samguk Sagi, the official history. So anyone who wants to check the Dangun story has to open the Samguk Yusa first. This can be seen as a condition worth knowing before comparing the two books.

Book One of the Samguk Yusa records the story of the bear and the tiger in relatively full detail. First, one bear and one tiger lived in the same cave. The two animals constantly prayed to Hwanung to make them human. Next, Hwanung gave them one bundle of divine mugwort and twenty cloves of garlic. Hwanung said, "If you eat this and do not see sunlight for a hundred days, you will become human." The ending, as seen above, was decided at samchil-il, that is on the 21st day.

The Samguk Yusa also recorded Hwanung's role. Hwanung commanded Pungbaek (風伯), Usa (雨師) and Unsa (雲師). He presided over grain and life, illness, punishment, and good and evil. He also presided over some 360 affairs of humankind, ruling and civilizing the human world. This passage can be read directly on the Samguk Yusa translation page at Wikisource. The account on the Jewang Ungi side can be checked in the corresponding entry of the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture.

Historic Korean woodblock-printed chronicle pages of the Samguk Yusa preserving the foundation records of Gojoseon and Dangun
Classical Korean historical woodblock text (Samguk Yusa, National Treasure) representing the 13th-century textual traditions of Iryeon’s Samguk Yusa and Yi Seung-hyu’s Jewang Ungi · 문화재청 (공공누리 제1유형) · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Dangun's age of 1,908 in the Samguk Yusa and the 1,038 years in the Jewang Ungi

The two books also recorded the numbers differently. The Samguk Yusa records that Dangun ruled the country for 1,500 years. It then records that Dangun hid himself at Asadal and became a mountain god (山神). His age at that time was 1,908. The Jewang Ungi records that Dangun ruled for 1,038 years. And it records that he entered Mount Asadal (阿斯達山) and became a god, which is why he did not die.

The genealogies do not line up either. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture compares the two records this way: "Although she is the same person in the sense of being Dangun's mother, on one side she is a woman incarnated from a bear, and on the other a woman incarnated from a god."

The same entry also notes the number of generations. In the Samguk Yusa, Dangun is the third generation in the paternal line, after Hwanin and Hwanung. In the Jewang Ungi, Dangun is the son of a woman from the fourth generation. Her family line runs from Hwanin to Hwanung.

A different genealogy is also carried within the Samguk Yusa itself. The Goguryeo section of the Samguk Yusa cited the Dangun-gi (壇君記). That record relates that Dangun united with the daughter of Habaek of Seoha (西河) and had a child named Buru. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture also notes the common substratum of the two records. The same encyclopedia summarizes that substratum as "a being that was not human takes medicine, obtains a human body, and becomes a woman."

The Jewang Ungi, published in 1287 and composed during the seclusion that began in 1280

Let us look at when the Jewang Ungi appeared. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture records that the Jewang Ungi was issued only a little more than ten years after the Samguk Yusa. The same encyclopedia states that the Jewang Ungi was published in 1287. The book was reprinted in 1360 and again in 1413. The gap between the publication of the two books is not long.

The circumstances of its composition are also recorded. In 1280, Yi Seung-hyu submitted a memorial listing more than ten abuses, criticizing King Chungnyeol's misrule and the pro-Yuan power holders. That act earned him disfavor, and he was dismissed from office and went into seclusion. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture records that the Jewang Ungi was composed during that period of seclusion.

The encyclopedia also describes how the book is structured. Its second volume deals with the history of Korea. This volume has two parts: the Dongguk gunwang gaeguk yeondae (東國君王開國年代) and the Bonjo gunwang segye yeondae (本朝君王世系年代).

The same encyclopedia also explains why the Jewang Ungi was written. The motive was a sense of cultural crisis and a spirit of resistance. Both grew out of overwhelming external pressure from the Mongols. The encyclopedia records that Iryeon wrote the Samguk Yusa in the same period with the same motive.

The encyclopedia also records one more point. The Dangun myth had been passed down through folk beliefs and ancient records. The Jewang Ungi incorporated it into the framework of Korean history.

Stone altar of Chamseongdan atop Mount Manisan on Ganghwa Island, traditionally associated with Dangun’s heaven-worship rituals
Chamseongdan Altar on Mount Manisan, Ganghwa Island, a historic stone altar associated with Korean foundation mythology and heaven-worship rites · Visually · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

The two books appeared only about a decade apart, and their motives for writing are described as the same. We can see that their accounts of Dangun diverged even within the same period and under the same motive.

The differences between the two records, set side by side point by point

Let us set the differences between the two records side by side, point by point. The first is how Dangun's name is written. The Samguk Yusa used the character dan (壇), meaning altar. The Jewang Ungi used the character dan (檀), meaning birch tree. The second is the documents each book cited. The Samguk Yusa cited the Wei shu and the Gogi, while the Jewang Ungi cited the Bongi.

The third is the mother. On one side she is a woman incarnated from a bear, and on the other a woman incarnated from a god. The fourth is the generation. The Dangun of the Samguk Yusa is the third generation in the paternal line. The Dangun of the Jewang Ungi is the son of a woman of the fourth generation of the family line.

The fifth is the division of Joseon. In its Gojoseon section, the Samguk Yusa recorded Dangun Joseon and Gija Joseon together. The Jewang Ungi described the Joseon of Dangun under the heading Jeon Joseon (前朝鮮, Former Joseon). Under the heading Hu Joseon (後朝鮮, Later Joseon) it mentioned the Joseon of Gija. And, including the Wiman Joseon that followed, it treated them as the Samjoseon (三朝鮮), the Three Joseons.

Laid out this way, we can see that the difference over the mother is just one of several. Still, the difference in cited sources and the difference over the mother merely sit side by side; this comparison does not tell us whether one caused the other.

Octagonal stone stupa standing on grass among trees
Stupa of National Preceptor Bogak (Iryeon), Ingaksa Temple, Gunwi · Unknown author Unknown author · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Summing up

To sum up. The Samguk Yusa recorded a woman transformed from a bear as Dangun's mother. The Jewang Ungi recorded a granddaughter of Hwanung, who became human after taking medicine, as Dangun's mother. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture summarizes the two Goryeo-period records as similar in their basic content but different in their details. The two books also cited different materials. However, no explanation identifying that difference in citation as what split the accounts of the mother has been confirmed.

It is worth looking at the later records along with these two. The Geography section of the Annals of King Sejong contains records about Dangun. In those records, the part of the story in question follows the Jewang Ungi.

The Jewang Ungi also began a historical consciousness of a Dangun era. This idea was passed on to the reform-minded new literati of the late Goryeo period. When they founded Joseon, Dangun was enshrined with state ritual as the national progenitor.

Official histories, including the Dongguk tonggam, also made it clear that Dangun was the national progenitor. They came to record him at the very head of Korean history. Reading the two records together, one can see this current emerge.

Fresh green Korean mugwort (Artemisia princeps) leaves growing in nature
Korean mugwort (Artemisia princeps)—in both the Samguk Yusa and Jewang Ungi accounts, sacred mugwort and twenty cloves of garlic serve as the ritual medicine of transformation · Qwert1234 · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons