The short answer: Asian dust is soil dust, fine dust is dust you breathe in

Asian dust and fine dust are not two names for the same thing. According to the Gangnam-gu card news, Asian dust is dust with a high share of soil components such as silicon. Fine dust, by contrast, contains large amounts of sulfates and nitrates.

They also start in different places. Asian dust forms mainly in northern China, the Mongolian desert regions and the Loess Plateau. Fine dust comes mainly from human activity. So the two can be seen as differing in both composition and origin.

By particle size alone, the two look much alike. The Gangnam-gu card news puts Asian dust particles at 5–8 μm, and among fine dust, PM-10 means dust 10 μm or less in diameter. On the numbers alone, Asian dust falls inside that range, so it can be said that size alone is a hard dividing line to draw. The proportions in which the two mix in the air cannot be confirmed from the sources used here.

How the Gangnam-gu card news defines fine dust, PM-10 and PM-2.5

The Gangnam-gu card news starts with a definition. Dust is particulate matter that floats in the air, or scatters and settles back down. Fine dust is the portion of that dust we inhale through the nose or mouth.

Two conditions underlie that definition. First, the material has to be particulate matter suspended in the air. Second, it has to enter the body through the nose or mouth.

The same material sorts fine dust into two categories. The line describing fine dust particles reads: "dust, pollen, mold and the like, 10 μm or less in diameter." That is PM-10. The line describing ultrafine particles reads: "combustion particles, organic compounds, metals and the like, 2.5 μm or less in diameter." That is PM-2.5. The two lines cite different examples of material.

NASA satellite image showing a plume of yellow mineral dust blowing from inland deserts across East Asia
NASA satellite view of an Asian dust (Hwangsa) plume carried by prevailing westerlies from inland deserts over the Korean Peninsula · Image courtesy the SeaWiFS Project, NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center, and ORBIMA · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

The PM-10 examples include pollen and mold. This suggests the label "fine dust" depends on particle size and whether it can be inhaled, not on where the dust comes from.

Asian dust at 5–8 μm: separated by origin and composition

The Gangnam-gu card news sums up the relationship in a single sentence. Its section on Asian dust states: "Asian dust particles are 5–8 μm in size, similar to fine dust, but on closer inspection there are differences in origin, composition and so on."

The sentence first notes that the two are similar in size. It then points to origin and composition as the features that set them apart.

So the dividing line between the two can be seen as composition and source region, rather than size.

It helps to set the categories side by side. In size, Asian dust measures 5–8 μm. PM-10 is 10 μm or less in diameter, and PM-2.5 is 2.5 μm or less.

In composition, Asian dust has a high share of soil components such as silicon. Fine dust, on the other hand, contains large amounts of sulfates and nitrates.

The sources differ too. Asian dust comes from northern China, the Mongolian desert regions and the Loess Plateau. Fine dust comes mainly from human activity.

By the numbers, Asian dust particles fall within the PM-10 range but are larger than the PM-2.5 threshold. The claim that their size is similar can be read as a comparison with PM-10.

▶ Official YouTube Video
KBS News
[Weather & Living Info] Similar Yet Different: Yellow Dust vs. Fine Dust — What's the Difference? Watch the video on YouTube →

Health effects of fine dust and flexible hours for sensitive groups

The Gangnam-gu card news also covers health effects. Fine dust particles are small enough to slip past the filtering action of the nose, mouth and bronchial tubes. They can then seep deep into the body.

Long exposure can trigger asthma, lung disease, cardiovascular disease and other illnesses. That is why the material urges caution. This material gives no separate figures for the health effects of Asian dust particles.

The same material also explains what to do. On days with heavy fine dust, the government recommends flexible working hours for sensitive groups. These include pregnant women and people with respiratory illness. The aim is to cut their exposure time.

You can also check real-time levels and forecasts by phone. AirKorea, which provides guidance on fine dust and Asian dust, lists the Weather Call Center at 131 for questions about real-time fine dust levels and forecasts. The number is listed as a paid call.

Seoul skyline shrouded in particulate haze reducing visibility across the city
Reduced urban visibility in Seoul during an episode of elevated particulate matter (PM10 and PM2.5) concentrations · taylorandayumi · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

The KMA's Asian dust observation days and AirKorea's country-by-country guide to the data

The Korea Meteorological Administration (KMA) publishes the number of Asian dust observation days for each station. Its table has monthly columns running from January through December.

For the Seoul station in 2001, the table shows 1 day in January, 11 in March, 9 in April, 4 in May and 2 in December. The remaining months show dots instead of numbers.

Judging by that single year, observation days cluster in March and April. Still, there are records in January and December as well.

AirKorea also lists Asian dust websites by country. For Korea, it lists the meteorological sector's Asian Dust Center. For Japan, it lists the Japan Meteorological Agency's dust measurement data.

The National Institute for Environmental Studies of Japan provides Lidar data covering Korea, Mongolia and Japan. The same institute runs CFORS, which forecasts Asian dust and anthropogenic pollutants across East Asia.

For China, the China Meteorological Administration's international weather center provides data on changes in surface concentrations during sand storms. The State Environmental Protection Administration (SEPA) provides air pollution index data for 47 Chinese cities.

American sources appear on the list as well. The ARL of the U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration provides Hysplit, a back-trajectory analysis tool. The name reads as meaning a method of retracing the path air has traveled.

Readers who want the original materials have two places to go. One is the table of Asian dust observation days on the KMA website. The other is the country-by-country list in AirKorea's guide to Asian dust websites.

In summary

Asian dust and fine dust are similar in size but different in composition. The Gangnam-gu card news describes Asian dust as dust with a high share of soil components such as silicon. It describes fine dust as dust containing large amounts of sulfates and nitrates.

Asian dust particles measure 5–8 μm. PM-10 is 10 μm or less in diameter, and PM-2.5 is 2.5 μm or less. So it can be said that one number alone is not enough to treat the two as the same thing.

When reading the data, match the agency to the specific category first. The KMA provides monthly Asian dust observation days by station, and AirKorea lists Asian dust websites for Korea, Japan, China and the United States. Questions about fine dust concentrations and forecasts go to the Weather Call Center at 131. Causes or trends beyond the scope of this article cannot be confirmed from the sources used here.

Arid sand dunes and gravel plains of the Gobi Desert, a primary source region for East Asian yellow dust
The arid terrain of the Gobi Desert, where spring cyclones loft natural mineral soil particles into the upper atmosphere · Siim Sepp ( Sandatlas ) · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons