The short answer: whether tropical Pacific sea surface temperatures run high or low

El Niño and La Niña are told apart by sea surface temperatures in the tropical Pacific. The KMA Climate Information Portal defines El Niño as a phenomenon in which those temperatures stay higher than usual for several months or more. This warming happens in the tropical eastern and central Pacific and recurs every two to five years. La Niña is its opposite. During La Niña, sea surface temperatures in the central and eastern Pacific fall below their usual levels. The trade winds also blow more strongly than normal. Put simply, a warmer-than-normal ocean means El Niño, and a cooler one means La Niña.

In Korea, the difference shows up in rainfall and temperature. According to the KMA Climate Information Portal, El Niño is at its strongest in November and December. Those months tend to bring more precipitation and higher temperatures to the Korean Peninsula. During La Niña, the same two months tend to be drier and colder.

NOAA describes the two as the warm and cool phases of ENSO, a natural climate pattern of the tropical Pacific. The easiest way to follow all this is to look first at the state of the ocean. Then look at the weather tendencies that follow.

NOAA Climate.gov's thresholds: 0.5°C in the Niño-3.4 region and five consecutive periods

NOAA puts numbers to the criteria in its ENSO guide on Climate.gov. El Niño conditions mean that the average sea surface temperature in the equatorial Pacific's Niño-3.4 region — the band spanning 5°N–5°S and 120°W–170°W — was at least 0.5°C above normal in the previous month. La Niña conditions mean the average there was at least 0.5°C below normal. Either way, the anomaly must also have lasted, or be expected to last, for five consecutive three-month running-average periods.

NOAA adds that the pattern swings back and forth irregularly every two to seven years. As it does, it changes ocean temperatures and disrupts the usual wind and rainfall patterns of the tropics. The KMA Climate Information Portal, for its part, describes El Niño's life cycle. It generally begins in spring or summer and develops through winter. It then gradually weakens and dies out the following spring or summer. Taken together, the two explanations suggest that a determination draws on both spatial and temporal criteria.

NOAA sea surface temperature anomaly map showing warm equatorial eastern Pacific waters during El Niño
Sea surface temperature anomaly map illustrating equatorial Pacific warming during an El Niño event · NASA image by Jesse Allen, using AMSR-E data processed and provided by Chelle Ge · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

What the JMA FAQ explains: trade winds, upwelling and the 1988/89 La Niña

The Japan Meteorological Agency (気象庁), Japan's weather agency, gives both a region and a duration in its El Niño FAQ. The region is the equatorial Pacific, from around the date line to the coast of South America. In El Niño, sea surface temperatures across these waters rise above normal and stay that way for about a year. When temperatures in the same waters remain below normal, the phenomenon is called La Niña.

The same source says each occurs at intervals of several years. It also explains how the term ENSO is often used. People use it when they view the Southern Oscillation and the two phenomena together as a single linked variation of atmosphere and ocean.

The JMA also traces the movements of wind and water. During El Niño, the easterly winds are weaker than usual. Warm water that had piled up in the west therefore spreads eastward. In the east, the upwelling of cold water weakens.

During La Niña, the easterlies blow more strongly than usual. Warm water piles up more thickly in the west. In the east, the upwelling of cold water grows stronger than usual.

The FAQ also offers a past case. The 1988/89 La Niña began in the spring of 1988, peaked in December 1988 and ended in the spring of 1989. The JMA considers El Niño and La Niña possible drivers of abnormal weather around the world, including in Japan.

This explanation shows that the difference in sea surface temperature moves together with changes in the easterly winds and upwelling. The 1988/89 case can be read as a way to check the 'about one year' duration against an actual calendar.

▶ Official YouTube Video
대한민국 기상청
Culprits of heat waves and cold snaps? El Niño and La Niña at a glance [Weather Study Lecture 45] Watch the video on YouTube →
A tall office tower with vertical-striped facade, trees and a sidewalk in front
Japan Meteorological Agency headquarters in Toranomon, Tokyo, 2020 · Europeans1145 · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

Comparing the definitions: regions and durations at the KMA, NOAA and JMA

The three agencies point to similar stretches of ocean but describe them differently. The KMA Climate Information Portal cites the tropical eastern and central Pacific. The JMA cites the equatorial Pacific from around the date line to the coast of South America. NOAA uses the Niño-3.4 region, in the equatorial Pacific, as its benchmark.

The wording on duration differs too. The KMA says several months or more, and the JMA says about a year. NOAA requires five consecutive three-month running-average periods. On frequency, the KMA says every two to five years. NOAA says every two to seven years, and the JMA says at intervals of several years. The 0.5°C numerical threshold comes from NOAA's explanation.

All three sources are publicly available, so readers can go straight to the originals. They are the KMA Climate Information Portal's climate prediction guide, NOAA's Climate.gov ENSO page and the JMA's El Niño FAQ.

NOAA's Climate Prediction Center works with the International Research Institute for Climate and Society (IRI). Together, they issue the official ENSO status update on the second Thursday of each month. When definitions seem to clash, it is arguably best to check first whose criteria are in play.

Oceanographic weather buoy moored at sea to monitor sea surface temperature and wind
An oceanographic weather buoy deployed to monitor sea surface temperatures, surface winds, and ENSO fluctuations · Lieutenant Elizabeth Crapo, NOAA Corps. · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Korea's impacts as compiled by the KMA Climate Information Portal: November 1982, 1997 and 2015

The KMA Climate Information Portal breaks Korea's tendencies down by period. From mid-July to mid-August, precipitation tends to increase during El Niño and decrease during La Niña. This happens mainly in the southern part of the Korean Peninsula. In September during La Niña, an anticyclonic flow settles to the southeast of the peninsula. A southerly airstream appears, bringing more precipitation and higher temperatures.

El Niño is at its strongest in November and December. In those months, precipitation tends to increase and temperatures tend to rise. In the same months during La Niña, precipitation tends to decrease and temperatures tend to fall.

The portal's section on effects over the Korean Peninsula names specific years: "The years in which November precipitation reached 100 mm or more — more than twice the normal amount — were 1982, 1997 and 2015, all years in which El Niño developed strongly."

NOAA, however, notes that the effects of El Niño and La Niña are weaker in the Northern Hemisphere summer than in winter. Taken together, the two explanations suggest that the strength of the signal varies with the season.

In summary

El Niño and La Niña are separated by whether tropical Pacific sea surface temperatures run above or below normal. The KMA Climate Information Portal describes the two as opposite states. NOAA offers a measurable test: a 0.5°C anomaly in the Niño-3.4 region sustained over five consecutive three-month running-average periods. The JMA gives a region and a duration of about a year, along with the shifts in the easterly winds and in upwelling.

The effects on Korea come as month-by-month tendencies. El Niño is at its strongest in November and December, and those months bring more precipitation and higher temperatures. In the same months during La Niña, there is less precipitation and temperatures are lower. Some explanations spell out the numbers, the months and the regions together. Choosing those, one could say, leaves less room for misunderstanding.

Deep tropical cumulonimbus convection clouds towering over the Pacific Ocean
Tropical Pacific atmospheric convection clouds that shift rainfall patterns across East Asia during El Niño and La Niña cycles · Giorgiogp2 · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons