The short answer: the gakgung is a short bow and a layered composite bow
Korea's gakgung (角弓) is classified in two ways. It is a short bow, with a limb span of no more than 2m. It is also a composite bow, built from water buffalo horn, ox sinew and bamboo. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, published by the Academy of Korean Studies, records it as both a short bow and a composite bow. The same encyclopedia records the Japanese bow as a long bow of plain wood. Mongolian bows and the equipment used in traditional Turkish archery are also recorded as using horn and sinew. The English longbow is recorded as a bow made from a single piece of yew.
The differences between these bows can therefore be seen as differences of material, length and systems of transmission. These sources alone make it hard to judge which bow is better. This comparison relies only on the figures recorded in the documents and the official designation records.
Six materials and four months of work: the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture on the gakgung
The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture lists six materials for the gakgung. They are water buffalo horn, ox sinew, bamboo, strips of mulberry wood, isinglass glue made from croaker swim bladders, and birch bark (樺皮). The same entry says a single bow takes about four months to make. It names October through March of the following year as the best window for the work. The reason is that animal glues such as croaker isinglass will not bond in humid, warm weather.
The same approach appears in our piece on why hanji does not tear easily, read through its materials and its making. That approach reads a material's character by separating its ingredients from how it is made.
Korean History On-line, a resource from the National Institute of Korean History, records that the gakgung and the pyeonjeon (片箭) developed considerably in the early Joseon period.
In 1488 Dong Yue (董越), an envoy from the Ming, came to Joseon. He assessed Joseon's birch-bark bow (樺皮弓). The same source notes that this bow was slightly shorter than the Chinese type. Even so, the force with which its arrows flew was extremely strong.
The pyeonjeon was a small arrow shot from a wooden tube called a tonga. The same source says it flew more than 1,000 paces to strike an enemy. It adds that under King Sejong, training in the pyeonjeon was banned in the Hamgyeong-do region.
The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture treats one gakgung separately. This bow is handed down as King Gojong's personal bow. It measures 124㎝ in overall length, with an ogeum width of 3㎝.
Tiger-tail mottling occasionally appears along the back ridge of water buffalo horn. This mottling is called homi. A gakgung made with horn plates showing homi was rated the better bow.
Oral tradition holds that Jang Mun-hwan (張文煥), a bowyer, made this bow and presented it to the court. It was designated an Important Folklore Material in 1976. The National Heritage Portal, run by the Korea Heritage Service, lists two related designation dates. Gungsijang carries a date of 13 September 1971, and archery carries a date of 30 July 2020.
This suggests the gakgung was made with the seasons in mind, not by skill alone. Dong Yue's remark shows that its combination of short length and strong force was noticed by an outside observer as well.
The Japanese bow: a long bow of plain wood in the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture
The 'Bow' entry in the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture divides bows into two kinds: long bows and short bows. Long bows have a limb span of 2m or more. They were used mainly by peoples of forest and coastal regions. Short bows usually span 2m or less. They were used by Korea, Mongolia and other steppe peoples.
The classification passage in the same entry reads: "Our gakgung (角弓) is both a short bow and a composite bow; its performance is outstanding and its range is long. The Japanese bow, by contrast, is a long bow, a bow of plain wood, and its range is short."
That sentence can be seen as both a classification and a judgement, made by a single encyclopedia.
For this article, we could not confirm any source that gives figures for the length of the Japanese bow or the position of its grip. So the specific length and structure of the Japanese bow remain unconfirmed.
The All Nippon Kyudo Federation (全日本弓道連盟) posts competition results on its website. They include the 77th Emperor's Cup All Japan Men's Kyudo Championship and the 59th Empress's Cup All Japan Women's Kyudo Championship. Those postings can be seen as a record that kyudo competitions continue in Japan.
Naadam and the Mongolian bow: a 2010 UNESCO inscription and six months to a year of work
Naadam is a festival held across Mongolia every year from 11 to 13 July. According to the UNESCO intangible heritage site, it centres on three sports: horse racing, wrestling and archery. It was inscribed on the Representative List of the Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity in 2010. This happened at the committee's fifth session, under nomination file number 00395.
The same description calls Naadam inseparably linked to the nomadic civilization of the Mongols. The three sports have traditionally been passed on through family instruction at home. Recently, structured training courses have appeared for wrestling and archery.
culture360 is run by the Asia-Europe Foundation. A contribution to it says Mongolian archers shoot with horn bows made from natural materials such as wood, horn and sinew. A single horn bow takes six months to a year to make. In cold weather the bow grows stronger and stiffer. In warm weather it softens, and the chance of hitting the target drops.
Male archers shoot from 45m in Buriad archery and from 75m in Khalkha archery. In competitions held inside Mongolia, adult archers must use only horn bows and arrows made in Mongolia.
The records say weather affects the gakgung when it is made and the Mongolian horn bow when it is shot. Both bows use horn and sinew, and neither can easily be understood apart from climate.
Turkish archery and the English longbow: a UNESCO decision and 172 bows from the Mary Rose
The UNESCO intangible heritage committee dealt with traditional Turkish archery in Decision 14.COM 10.B.38. Türkiye had nominated the practice for the Representative List as file no. 01367. The decision notes several disciplines, performed both on foot and on horseback. It lists the equipment materials as wood grown in specific highland climates, organic glues, horn, sinew, silk and leather.
The practice entered Türkiye's national inventory of intangible cultural heritage in 2014. Many provinces were added in 2018. The committee decided to inscribe traditional Turkish archery on the Representative List.
Material from the Mary Rose Trust describes the longbows recovered from the Mary Rose. Of the 250 recorded as carried on board, 172 were recovered, along with more than 2,000 complete arrows and roughly 7,000 fragments. Every longbow was made from a single piece of yew and includes the boundary between heartwood and sapwood. Lengths range from 1,839mm to 2,113mm, and estimated draw weights fall between 65 and 175 pounds, clustering most heavily around 110 pounds.
Set side by side under the same headings, the four cases show where they diverge.
Start with materials. The Korean gakgung uses water buffalo horn, ox sinew, bamboo, strips of mulberry wood, croaker isinglass glue and birch bark. The Mongolian bow uses wood, horn and sinew. Turkish archery equipment adds silk and leather to those. The English longbow comes from a single piece of yew.
On length, the surviving gakgung measures 124㎝, while the Mary Rose longbows are recorded at 1,839 to 2,113mm. On records, gungsijang was designated in 1971 and Naadam was inscribed in 2010. Turkish archery entered the national inventory in 2014.
| Bow | Main materials | Length and classification | Key record |
|---|---|---|---|
| Korean gakgung | Water buffalo horn, ox sinew, bamboo, strips of mulberry wood, croaker isinglass glue, birch bark | Short bow (limb span 2m or less), composite bow; surviving bow of King Gojong 124㎝ | Gungsijang designated 13 September 1971; archery designated 30 July 2020 |
| Japanese bow | Wood and bamboo (classified under plain-wood longbows) | Classified as a long bow of plain wood (Encyclopedia of Korean Culture) | All Nippon Kyudo Federation posts results of the 77th Emperor's Cup and 59th Empress's Cup championships |
| Mongolian bow | Wood, horn, sinew | Composite bow (traditional steppe archery) | Naadam inscribed on the UNESCO Representative List in 2010, file no. 00395 |
| Turkish bow | Highland wood, organic glues, horn, sinew, silk, leather | Short reflex composite bow | Entered the national inventory in 2014; inscription decided in Decision 14.COM 10.B.38 |
| English longbow | A single piece of yew | 1,839mm–2,113mm | 172 longbows from the Mary Rose, estimated draw weights 65–175 pounds |
The Mary Rose longbows range from just under to just over the 2-metre line. This suggests the encyclopedia's split between long and short bows is better read as a rough guide than a strict boundary.
In summary
The gakgung is recorded as a short bow and as a composite bow built from layered materials. Two sources note its short length alongside its strong force: Dong Yue's assessment of 1488 and the classification in the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture. Bows in other countries are recorded with different materials, lengths and systems of transmission. These sources offer little basis for reading those differences as a ranking.
The original texts are available in two places. One is the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, published by the Academy of Korean Studies. The other is Korean History On-line, from the National Institute of Korean History. Designation records sit on the National Heritage Portal of the Korea Heritage Service. Inscription records are on the UNESCO intangible heritage site. The material on the Mary Rose longbows is on the Mary Rose Trust website.