1. The moment “we got married” becomes legally true

Wedding photographs usually show a venue or a chapel, guests, and rings. But at which moment in those pictures did the two people become legally married? The answer differs by country.

In some countries, it is the moment they said “yes” before a town-hall official. In others, it is the moment a form was accepted at a government counter. In others still, it is the moment a member of the clergy pronounced them married. So the same photograph can mean different things. In France, it can show “a blessing for a couple already married at the town hall.” In Korea, it can show “a ceremony for two people who are legally single until they file their marriage report.”

This article looks at three types of country and how each makes a marriage legal. The first type recognizes only civil marriage: France, the Netherlands, and Germany. In the second type, filing alone creates the marriage: Korea and Japan. The third type recognizes religious and civil ceremonies side by side: England and Wales. Finally, the article looks at how “who may marry” has changed, drawing on the cases of the Netherlands and the United States. Every statement rests on the governments’ own guidance or the text of the law.

2. France: town hall first, church second, and a penalty for getting the order wrong

The French government’s public-service guide summarizes the procedure plainly. The marriage “must be celebrated at the town hall (mairie), in a room open to the public.” The banns are “notices posted on the door of the town hall by the civil registrar.” A ten-day waiting period follows the banns. The wedding must then take place within the following year.

Then comes one more line: “It is forbidden to celebrate a religious marriage before the civil marriage.”

That prohibition is backed by France’s Penal Code. In 2007, a written question was put in the French Senate, and the government replied. Both cite Article 433-21 of the Penal Code. This article punishes “any minister of religion who habitually performs religious marriage ceremonies without having been shown the marriage certificate previously drawn up by the civil registrar.”

The reply also confirms that the article “applies to all religions, without any distinction and whatever form the religious ceremony may take.” The penalty quoted at the time was six months’ imprisonment and a fine of 7,500 euros.

In other words, in France a wedding in a church, cathedral, or mosque does not create a marriage in law. If the order is reversed, the officiant bears the responsibility. The principle that only the state makes a marriage is enforced by criminal law.

Historic European town hall (Rathaus/Mairie) where civil marriage ceremonies are legally performed before a registrar
A European municipal hall where civil marriage before a state registrar is mandatory for legal validity prior to any religious ceremony · Peng ( talk ) 11:56, 8 November 2009 (UTC) · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

3. The Netherlands and Germany: only the declaration before the registrar is a marriage

The Dutch government’s marriage guide states the same principle in gentler words: “After your marriage or civil partnership ceremony has been conducted by the registrar you may hold a religious ceremony in a church or mosque, if you wish. The religious ceremony may not take place before the civil ceremony.”

The requirements are equally clear. Both partners must be 18 or older. Neither may be married to, or in a civil partnership with, anyone else. The couple “will need to appoint at least 2 and no more than 4 witnesses,” and these witnesses “must be 18 years or older.”

Germany fixes the principle in a single sentence of its Civil Code. Section 1310(1) of the German Civil Code (BGB) provides that “the marriage is concluded only if the parties contracting the marriage declare before the registrar (Standesbeamter) that they wish to enter into the marriage.” It adds that the registrar “may not refuse to cooperate in the conclusion of the marriage if the prerequisites for concluding the marriage are met.”

The key phrase is “only if” (nur dadurch). In Germany a marriage exists in one form alone: the declaration before the registrar. A church wedding is a separate event with no legal effect.

4. Korea: a form, not a ceremony, makes the marriage

In Korea, a marriage comes into being neither at the town hall nor in a church, but on paper. The Ministry of Government Legislation’s Easy-to-Find Law guide lists three requirements.

First, the parties must agree to marry. Without agreement, the marriage is void (Civil Code Article 815). Second, they must have reached marriageable age: “a person who has turned 18 may marry,” though a minor needs the consent of parents or guardian (Articles 807 and 808). Third, “a marriage takes effect only when a marriage report is filed under the Act on Registration of Family Relations (Civil Code Article 812(1)).”

The same guide describes the filing procedure, which makes the structure even clearer. A marriage report is “a report of the fact of marriage to the head of the city (district), town, or township.” The guide adds that “because a marriage takes effect by filing, there is no separate filing deadline.” The form must be “co-signed by two adult witnesses.”

The law takes no interest in when, where, or how the wedding ceremony is held. A couple who never hold a ceremony become spouses by filing alone. On the other hand, a couple who hold a lavish wedding but never file are, in law, in a de facto marriage. That is why Koreans have two “wedding dates”: the day of the ceremony and the day of registration.

Bride and groom signing an official marriage register document with a pen
Signing the official marriage register, the decisive legal step in civil-registration jurisdictions · Albert Anker · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

5. Japan: the moment it is written into the family register, and why “a church wedding alone is not enough”

Japan, too, is a filing-based country. The Ministry of Justice’s guide explains what the family register is. It is an official document that records and certifies a Japanese national’s nationality and such major matters as birth, marriage, divorce, and death. These matters are recorded “on the basis of notifications (birth notification, marriage notification, divorce notification, death notification, and so on).”

A marriage is created by submitting a marriage notification (婚姻届) at a city, ward, town, or village office. The marriage is then entered in the family register.

The ministry’s Q&A on international marriage shows the same principle from the other side. It answers a Japanese national who held a wedding abroad: “Holding a wedding ceremony abroad may in some cases create a legally valid marriage under that country’s law, but in other cases, as when a ceremony is held in a church in Japan or Hawaii, the ceremony alone cannot be treated as having created a legally valid marriage.”

What happens next depends on the case. If a marriage was validly concluded under foreign law, a copy of the marriage certificate must be submitted so that the marriage can be entered in the register. It goes to a Japanese consulate or the municipality of the registered domicile, “within three months of the date the marriage was concluded.” If no marriage exists, the couple must “conclude a marriage in the Japanese manner again,” that is, file a notification.

In Japan, the law takes no notice of a church wedding. What it recognizes is the date written in the register.

6. England and Wales: church or register office, either one is a legal marriage

England and Wales take a third path. The UK government’s guide says that “you can choose to have either a religious ceremony or a civil ceremony if you’re getting married.” A religious wedding “can take place at any registered religious building.” A civil ceremony can be held at “a register office” or “any venue approved by the local council, for example a stately home or hotel.”

Either way, “you must have at least 2 witnesses at the ceremony.” For a civil ceremony, “a registrar must carry out, or be present at, your ceremony.” For a religious ceremony, couples are told to check whether the venue has an authorised person. If it does not, they should book a registrar.

Both paths begin in the same way, with “giving notice.” Couples “must sign a legal statement at your local register office to say you intend to get married.” They must do this “at least 29 days before your ceremony,” and they “must hold your ceremony within 12 months of ‘giving notice’.” They must also have lived in the district for at least 7 days. The process of giving notice may be different for Church of England weddings.

After the ceremony, the couple, the witnesses, and the registrar sign a “schedule.” It is sent to the register office and entered in the register. Unlike in France, in England a religious ceremony can itself be the legal marriage. Couples also have another option: they “can get a religious blessing of your marriage after a civil ceremony.”

The Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Act 2013 received Royal Assent on 17 July 2013. It allowed same-sex couples to marry in England and Wales. The government guide explains that same-sex couples “can get married in a religious building if it has been registered for the marriage of same-sex couples.”

Central aisle and altar of a church prepared for a wedding ceremony
A church nave and altar—in countries like the United States and the United Kingdom, licensed religious officiants can solemnize legally binding marriages · Ansgar Koreng · CC BY 3.0 de · Wikimedia Commons

7. Who may marry: Amsterdam in 2001 and Washington in 2015

Where a marriage becomes legal is one question. Who may marry is another, and that has changed sharply over the past quarter century. The Pew Research Center published a summary in March 2026. According to it, “the world’s first nationally recognized same-sex marriages” were “performed in the Netherlands in April 2001.” On 1 April 2001, four couples were married at Amsterdam City Hall.

Pew continues: “Belgium was the next to do so in 2003, followed by Canada and Spain in 2005.” The most recent additions were “Estonia, Greece and Nepal in 2024 and Liechtenstein and Thailand in 2025.” The Dutch government’s page still puts it in one sentence: “In the Netherlands it is possible for two men or two women to marry.”

In the United States, the change came from a court judgment, not a new law. On 26 June 2015, the Supreme Court decided Obergefell v. Hodges. The case concerned laws in Michigan, Kentucky, Ohio, and Tennessee that “define marriage as a union between one man and one woman.”

The Court held that “the Fourteenth Amendment requires a State to license a marriage between two people of the same sex and to recognize a marriage between two people of the same sex when their marriage was lawfully licensed and performed out-of-State.” The opinion described the right to marry as a “fundamental right.” It found that denying this right to same-sex couples violated both the Due Process Clause and the Equal Protection Clause.

Where a marriage is created was still a matter for each state’s licensing system. But who must be allowed to marry became a matter for the federal Constitution.

8. What the three types show together

First, marriage is a legal event defined by the state, and a ceremony may or may not coincide with it. In France, the Netherlands, and Germany, a marriage can be made only before a state registrar. In Korea and Japan, the law ignores the ceremony entirely. In England and Wales, the state has kept both paths open by sharing its registration authority with religious buildings and clergy.

Second, in some countries the order of events is itself the law. In France and the Netherlands, a religious ceremony may take place “only after” the civil marriage. In France, clergy who break the rule can be punished under the Penal Code. The rule is a trace of the history that moved marriage from religion to the state. It is also the difference that couples marrying across borders most often run into.

Third, the date on the document is the real date. Korea’s filing date, Japan’s register entry, England’s signed schedule, and Germany’s declaration before the registrar are each the legal wedding day. A couple marrying across two countries has to check not one wedding date but which document in which country will carry which date. Marriage is a promise of love; in the eyes of the law it is a document produced in a particular place before a particular person.