The short answer: a map that gave up area to keep direction
The Mercator projection gives up accurate area in exchange for accurate direction. That is why Greenland looks about the same size as Africa on a world map. In fact, UN News reports that Africa is about 14 times larger.
Korea's National Geographic Information Institute (NGII) defines map projection as the process of transferring the round Earth onto a flat surface, such as paper. By that account, distortion remains at the point where the globe is flattened.
The U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) states that every flat map misrepresents the surface of the Earth in some way. So rather than asking whether a map is wrong, it may be better to ask what it preserves and what it gives up. Mercator preserves direction and gives up area.
Every flat map distorts something — the USGS map projection FAQ
The USGS map projection FAQ page makes the point that distortion cannot be avoided. No flat map can match a globe when it comes to representing the entire surface of the Earth truthfully.
The same page describes the Mercator projection. In substance, it reads: "The basic Mercator projection is the only map on which a straight line drawn anywhere within its boundaries shows true direction, but distances and areas on Mercator projection maps are badly distorted near the map's polar regions."
That rendering conveys the sense rather than the exact original wording. The original can be read directly on the FAQ page of the USGS website.
NGII likewise notes that no map can show distance, direction, shape and area all accurately at once. NOAA's Office of Coast Survey describes how a nautical chart is flattened: positions on a sphere are mathematically projected onto a cylindrical surface.
UN News reports that area was the price paid for preserving direction. The same report notes that landmasses look progressively larger the farther they lie from the equator. Set the two explanations side by side, and the distortion looks less like a mistake than like the result of a choice.
A projection published in 1569 and the realities of chart work — NOAA's nautical cartography guide
UN News reports that the Flemish cartographer Gerardus Mercator devised the projection in 1569 to solve a practical problem of sea navigation. NOAA's Office of Coast Survey likewise gives 1569 as the first publication of the rectangular Mercator projection. NGII explains that the projection was built for long-distance voyages, because a ship can sail between two points on a single constant bearing.
NOAA explains in terms of straight lines why most nautical charts use the Mercator projection. A straight line drawn on the chart is a line of constant course, called a rhumb line. ECDIS and many other navigation systems that use electronic navigational chart (ENC) data also display in Mercator. The agency's chart scales run from 1:2,500 to 1:10 million. Publication of traditional paper charts ended in 2024.
NGII notes that there is no distortion of area around the equator, where the cylinder touches the globe. The distortion grows more severe toward the poles. So if you compare areas using a projection built for the sea, you can expect the mismatch to grow large.
The 2026 UN General Assembly resolution A/80/L.104 and the Equal Earth projection
The UN Office of the Special Adviser on Africa (OSAA) states that the General Assembly adopted resolution A/80/L.104, "Correct the Map", on 4 September 2026. The push was led by Togo and the African Union.
UN News reports that the vote was 164 to 1. The United States cast the only vote against, calling the initiative part of a "radical ideological project". Six countries abstained: Estonia, Georgia, Lithuania, Moldova, Serbia and Ukraine.
Hours before the vote, French Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot announced plans to abandon the Mercator projection on world maps.
OSAA explains that the resolution neither bans the Mercator projection nor mandates a replacement. Instead, it encourages the use of equal-area maps, such as the Equal Earth projection, when relative size matters. It also recommends teaching the limits of flat maps in representing a spherical planet.
Equal-area maps do not enlarge Africa, OSAA notes. They strip away the exaggeration Mercator gives to land near the poles.
The resolution points to the Equal Earth projection, developed in 2018, as a projection that shows relative size more accurately.
A 2019 paper published by Monash University, "The Equal Earth map projection", introduces it as an equal-area pseudocylindrical projection for world maps. It took its inspiration from the widely used Robinson projection. Unlike the Robinson, however, it preserves the relative areas of regions. Its projection equations are also simple to implement and fast to compute.
NGII, for its part, describes the Peters projection as accurate in area but unlike reality in shape.
It is worth noting that the resolution recommends choosing by purpose rather than imposing a ban. This shows that the debate turns less on whether a map is right or wrong than on what it is used for.
Which projections institutions and publications actually use
Put the same question to different institutions, and their choices differ. The USGS used only the polyconic projection for decades. Today its published maps use several common projections.
For large-scale maps, such as topographic quadrangles and the State Base Map series, it uses conformal projections. Examples include the transverse Mercator and the Lambert conformal conic. The agency explains that its 1:24,000 7.5-minute topographic maps, based on the transverse Mercator, are nearly accurate in every respect.
On small-scale Mercator world maps, distortion at high latitudes is extreme. Yet a transverse Mercator map can correctly position a narrow area at the same high latitude, and there that distortion all but disappears.
Item by item, it looks like this. NOAA's Office of Coast Survey uses the Mercator projection for nautical charts, at scales from 1:2,500 to 1:10 million.
In 1987 the USGS published John P. Snyder's "Map projections: A working manual" as Professional Paper 1395. Its main text runs to 385 pages, and Crossref counts 674 publications citing the report. The same agency designed the Space Oblique Mercator to map the Earth continuously from satellites with low distortion.
NGII makes Korea's domestic maps with the transverse Mercator projection, which turns the cylinder 90 degrees to minimise distortion. Since 2011, it has produced its world maps with the Robinson projection. Readers curious about area figures can also read our separate article on Korea's land area.
A paper in the Journal of the Korean Cartographic Association set out to find the most suitable projection for maps of the area around South Korea. It weighed four candidates: the Lambert conformal conic, the Albers equal-area conic, the Lambert azimuthal equal-area and the azimuthal equidistant projections.
For the distortion analysis, a local distortion index at infinitesimal scale was judged the most appropriate measure. PDAT (Projection Distortion Analysis Tool), built on that index, served as the analysis platform. After the overall review, the final choice was the Lambert azimuthal equal-area projection.
The paper can be found on the article information page of the National Research Foundation of Korea's KCI portal.
| Institution or publication | Projection used | Figures and years given in the source |
|---|---|---|
| NOAA Office of Coast Survey, nautical cartography guide | Mercator projection (charts and ECDIS display) | Scales 1:2,500 to 1:10 million; paper chart publication ended in 2024; projection published in 1569 |
| U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) map projection FAQ | 7.5-minute topographic maps based on the transverse Mercator | Scale 1:24,000; 18 projections on the poster |
| USGS Professional Paper 1395 | Transverse Mercator, Lambert conformal conic, Space Oblique Mercator | Published 1987; main text 385 pages; 674 citations on Crossref |
| National Geographic Information Institute (NGII), map projection | Transverse Mercator for domestic maps, Robinson for world maps | World maps since 2011; cylinder turned 90 degrees |
| Journal of the Korean Cartographic Association paper (KCI) | Lambert azimuthal equal-area selected as the final projection | 4 candidate projections compared using the PDAT analysis platform |
| UN General Assembly resolution A/80/L.104 | Equal-area maps such as Equal Earth encouraged | Adopted 4 September 2026; 164 to 1; 6 countries abstained; Equal Earth developed in 2018 |
The list shows that even a single institution uses different projections for domestic maps and world maps. Just as the transverse Mercator is nearly accurate over a narrow area, distortion can be read as depending more on scale and coverage than on the name of the projection.
Wrapping up
The answer lies in what the projection was for. Mercator keeps direction and gives up area, all for the sake of navigation. That is why Greenland looks much like Africa on a map, while UN News reports that Africa is about 14 times larger. No map, NGII notes, can be accurate in distance, direction, shape and area all at once.
OSAA sums it up: no projection can reproduce the Earth's curved surface perfectly on a flat plane. Each one sacrifices some of area, shape, distance and direction, and each suits different uses. The USGS states that shape is somewhat distorted on all equal-area maps.
The 2026 resolution is not binding, and the Mercator projection is not going away. So choosing a map can be said to come down to what you are trying to compare.